Media Clipping — Sunday March 2, 2008, The Chronicale Herald

From knowledge to wisdom

By Silver Donald Cameron

One of the greatest intellectual skills is the ability to ask good questions, which is a prerequisite for discovering good answers. Nobody asks better questions than GPI Atlantic.

The Faithful Reader already knows my admiration for this little research organization from St. Margaret's Bay, which has done so much to help us think more intelligently about the world and the frantic social flux we live in. GPI, you'll recall, stands for Genuine Progress Index, as opposed to Gross Domestic Product, which has become our conventional but unsatisfactory - indicator of progress.

The GDP is only about money. Increased sales of cars and cannelloni make the GDP go up, yes but so do crime, disease and disasters. When hurricane Juan strikes, the GDP counts all the costs of cleanup as economic growth, and thus as "progress." The GPI, by contrast, counts things that are destructive and harmful as negatives and deducts them from our overall well-being. Sounds like common sense? Yes, exactly.

In the past decade, GPI Atlantic has issued more than 80 reports about Nova Scotian society on topics as diverse as the social costs of obesity and tobacco use, the unrecognized cash value of volunteerism and unpaid housework, the destructive irrationality of our treatment of forests and fisheries. Each report is a piece of the Genuine Progress Index of Nova Scotia. When the index is complete, we will have a unique description of Nova Scotia's quality of life, and a solid set of benchmarks against which to measure future progress or decline.

GPI Atlantic's most recent report, just issued, is entitled How Educated Are Nova Scotians? Education Indicators for the Nova Scotia Genuine Progress Index.

Predictably, the study reviewed such data as test scores, literacy, student debt and research financing. It came up with some interesting findings, for example, that the increasing reliance of schools on fundraising is slowly creating a two-tiered education system, where schools in wealthy neighbourhoods are much better equipped than schools in poorer districts.

The study reported that Nova Scotian university students graduate with a very heavy debt load, and that they work longer hours during the academic term than they ever have. It also revealed, rather shockingly, that although Nova Scotians today have more schooling than ever before, they are no more literate than they were a generation ago.

The usual report on education would have ended there, basing its findings on the assumption that "education" means "what the education system does." Instead, the GPI report turned the process on its head, asking not, "What do students learn?" but "What do Nova Scotians know no matter where or how they learned it?" So the GPI Atlantic study considered modes of learning that lie beyond the formal education system. "Life-long learning" is the intellectual progress that continues throughout the individual's lifetime. Life-wide learning is the education that takes place in informal settings like the home, the workplace, and the community, and through advertising and the media.

The end result of life-long and life-wide learning is a wide range of "literacies." The GPI Atlantic team therefore attempted to assess Nova Scotians' command not only of languages and numbers, but also their understanding of science, ecology, health, nutrition, civics, arts, culture, statistics, indigenous knowledge, and the media.

We don't have much data on the general level of public understanding, but GPI executive director Ronald Colman notes that high levels of literacy in these matters should be revealed in wise collective choices and intelligent public policies.

Alas, the report found little evidence that Nova Scotians are particularly literate in most of these areas, and in some, civics and politics, for example, younger people are actually less literate than their parents and grandparents, although they have much more schooling.

As is so often the case, the research was badly hampered by a lack of information.

"We don't know how literate our people are on all those dimensions, and we don't know whether their literacy levels in these and other knowledge areas are improving or not," said Colman. So GPI Atlantic Statistics Canada will begin administering a Canadian Knowledge Survey, which would provide an evolving picture of population knowledge and wisdom clearly an essential step.

For me, however, the report's greatest contribution is its deep insight into the purposes of education. Learning starts with data, but it soon progresses to information and then to knowledge and its final destination is wisdom. Understanding, otherwise known as literacy, is the factor that connects all four levels. Without a broad spectrum of literacies, there is no possibility of attaining wisdom. And without wisdom, there is no possibility of creating a truly humane society and a sustainable way of life. In its deepest and broadest sense, that's really what education is all about and by reminding Nova Scotians of that fact, a report like How Educated are Nova Scotians does us a signal public service.

Without a broad spectrum of literacies, there is no possibility of attaining wisdom.

Copyright © 2008, The Chronicle Herald